Moodle Blog

Moodle Blog9: Why Moodle? Challenging the Cynics

There is much discussion in education circles, not least in the fora of the TES , of the merits of VLEs such as Moodle. There are those who claim Moodle is another fad which will fall out of favour, never having proved its educational value. And then there are those who actually use it.

So what are the arguments exactly? For – that it engages students because they get to go ‘on the computers’, that teachers can put their resources on it, even deliver lessons on if for students to do in their absence and get said work marked for them by Moodle while they go down the pub.

Against? Well, apart from the fact that giving teachers more drinking time down the pub might not be construed as long-term beneficial, some people see them as no more than a graveyard for dead Word docs. If that’s the ethos in your school then I’m afraid your VLE is terminal. VLEs don’t just have to be a repository for last month’s Word doc homework; they can provide examples of levelled tasks, marking criteria; they can showcase excellence; students can upload , share,comment on videos, animations, podcasts; parents can get a look in at what their child’s up to…

At which point the argument of the cynics changes tack:

But where is the proof that a VLE can enhance learning? That will improve grades? (Because if there is no proof, then obviously it isn’t worth bothering with…) I confess now to being the Arch cynic because I am not sure there ever has been any one factor, certainly not in my 2 decades of teaching that has enhanced learning or improved grades. (And where grades have improved, the cry is always of ‘lowered standards!’ so you can’t win) The key to remember is that just because there is no magic solution doesn’t mean you shouldn’t try new initiatives. If they work for a while and if they work for some, then go for it. VLEs have a better chance of working than most ‘fads’ because they tap into the current psyche of the teenager – get everything online and get it NOW. And as long as the internet survives, so will Moodle.

Which then leads to the argument that learning will just become too mechanised, students will become automatons – click here click there –type in this box – you got 100% well done – now go to Maths to do the same. Where’s the human element? Still there; of course it is and always will be, fads or not, Moodle or not. In the schools such as Our Lady’s Preston where Moodle is used to great effect, it complements, not replaces good class teaching. This is what we emphasise in our Moodle training sessions. Yes there are the forums and the wikis and the workshops to share ideas in cyberspace but there is still the classroom and the human voice and Danny will still come in ten minutes late smelling of smoke. I remember early on in high school in 1971 and having to write an essay for my English teacher speculating on the classroom of the future. I, along with most of my classmates wrote of these huge, computery things which would teach us all we needed to know and Mr Green would be out of a job. Naively I thought then – but presciently as it turned out – he commented on my efforts in red: do you really think there will be no place for teachers in the future? Moodle is the teachers assistant, not their replacement. If it is well prepared and involves the students, they’ll learn; if it isn’t – they won’t.

Dieser Beitrag wurde am Saturday, 26. January 2008 um 22:40 Uhr veröffentlicht und wurde unter der Kategorie Moodle abgelegt. Du kannst die Kommentare zu diesen Eintrag durch den RSS-Feed verfolgen. Du hast die Möglichkeit einen Kommentar zu hinterlassen, oder einen Trackback von deinem Weblog zu senden.

«  –  »

4 Comments »

  1. Mary, you make a compelling case. I have recently been included in my school’s ICT committee and will be having a meeting with SMT after the holidays regarding our awful website, which was created using an awful content management system called EasySite. I want to present to them the idea of substituting it with a VLE, such as Moodle. Can you direct me to websites that might offer real examples of what Moodle can do, so I can show them the light? Many thanks.
    José

    Comment: José Picardo – 20. March 2008 @ 8:40 am

  2. Hi Jose – email me if you need more specific info but in the meantime – point them in the direction of our Moodle http://vle.olchs.lancs.sch.uk and go to All Courses – the ones with the little face icon are open access so they could have a look. The main point is that it functions both as a website/showcase on the open front page and also a VLE. We do have a website at http://www.olchs.lancs.sch.uk but it is static – more of a prospectus really – and soon will become a part of the Moodle (as a book, in fact, linked to from the front page). I suggest you join the VLE/Moodle forum at http://www.effectiveict.co.uk where there are other keen Moodlers !

    Comment: admin – 24. March 2008 @ 4:18 pm

  3. Hi Mary

    Hear you loud and clear across the oceans !

    I got myself a little battery of ready responses to unhelpful doubters of Moodle (you know, the ones that first look at WHAT IS WRONG not what they could use things for) at http://human.edublogs.org/2008/10/09/top-5-myths-about-teaching-with-moodle/
    They speak a lot to what you speak of here…

    However, much like you I remain a helpful doubter of anything that gets in the way of claims to improve the art of teaching.

    Regards & thanks for your insights.

    Tomaz
    http://human.edublogs.org

    Comment: Tomaz Lasic – 10. October 2008 @ 2:42 pm

  4. Hi there Tomaz! Thanks for your thoughts 🙂

    Comment: Mary – 10. October 2008 @ 11:04 pm

Leave a comment

Pages

The Blog Posts

Search the blog

Meta

 

WP-Design: Vlad -- Powered by WordPress -- XHTML 1.0